Circle Makers Speak #13: Q&A Session (Part Two)
INTRODUCTION
We launched Circle Makers Speak after our Instagram account Crop Circle Explorer ran a brief question and answer session with a human circle maker. In mid-2025 we decided to repeat the exercise and received more than 70 questions from curious readers.
We have collated the best of these questions and reproduce them here, together with answers from a very real human circle maker.
Due to the length of this piece we have decided to split it into a series. Here is the second of the three installments. (Part one can be read by clicking here.)
ONE

What are the biggest challenges involved in making crop circles?
I think there are two huge challenges. The first is getting into the field. Not on a logistical level, but in terms of obtaining the necessary manpower. As circle making is a dying art it is becoming increasingly difficult to get a competent team together to get into a field at the same time. There are fewer of us these days, and all of us have lives and commitments beyond the fields. None of us are getting any younger.
On a more practical basis, the second major issue is finding somewhere where you can work safely. Farmers seem much more alert to the prospect of rural crime these days, though that’s more down to burglaries, thefts and hare coursing than crop circles. You have to scout a potential location for the presence of trail or security cameras, and gone are the days where you could drive into a field and park up your vehicle in a discreet corner. Even laybys are uninviting as the police regularly stop to inspect solitary vehicles in rural locations overnight. So you have to be careful, think ahead and choose your fields very carefully.
TWO
How do you feel if your crop circle is cut out by the farmer?
There’s a myth that circle makers get annoyed when farmers cut out their circles. Yes, it’s nice if the circle is left intact because people can visit or view it, but that isn’t a consideration for me when I go into a field. Very few croppies visit circles and I’d only get annoyed if a circle is cut out before it has been photographed from the air or ground. Fortunately that has never happened to me, although I can think of one occasion when it almost did.
I’m very much of the opinion that when a farmer finds a crop circle they are perfectly entitled to do what they want with it. Mow it out, roll it, leave it alone. It’s their field and their crop so they can follow whatever course they want. I understood that from the first moment I used a stomper. I’m very philosophical on this one.
THREE

How do the public know the difference between a human circle and a UFO [made] circle?
I find croppies like to cherry pick what they want from crop circles to suit their own argument. None of them can agree on what the physical traits of a genuine circle are. I think there’s a good reason for that. They can’t do it because it isn’t possible.
Anyone who says real crop circles show specific features is guessing. Do the plant nodes have to be bent or blown or straight? Should the crop heads be straight or bent over? What about the layering effects you get in barley when the crop starts to stand back up? That used to be a mark of genuineness, but now people say it only happens in hoaxes. It’s the same with the lay of the crop when it is flattened. What’s the real thing? The lay that flows in the same direction, or the lay that is crossed? There’s no consensus.
FOUR
Why don’t you guys leave like a signature or mark so people know?
Sometimes we do. On the occasions we don’t it is done for a reason.
A good signature should be subtle and cryptic, but something that keeps popping up in your circles time after time. If you look back at ground level photos from the first decade of the 2000s you can start to notice little features repeating themselves.
I’m not a fan of obvious signatures. They tell the whole world that you were responsible. You may as well just go and tag a wall with paint. That ‘FOJ’ you used to see stomped alongside circles in the past was the most brazen example.
I know signatures still appear in today’s circles, but you don’t see too many close up photographs anymore, so they tend to pass unnoticed.
FIVE

What is the most dangerous part of making a crop circle?
I always think leaving the field when you’ve finished is the most dangerous time. Everyone is feeling tired and you just want to get home or find somewhere to put your head down. When you feel like that you can make some rash decisions. I can remember a few times when I’ve walked back to our transport, stomper in hand, along the side of a road. I was too tired to care.
The worst feeling though is waiting to be picked up at the roadside when there’s a big crop circle in the field behind you. You have to hide in the shadows and be certain that the car or van which has pulled up is your transport. It’s a feeling of complete helplessness as you’ve no idea what the next vehicle coming around the corner is going to be and who will be in it.
SIX
Have you ever seen [a crop circle] you believed was not man made?
When I was a kid interested in crop circles I saw plenty I believed were man made. I really thought aliens were hovering above the fields and zapping pictures into the crops. Looking back, it would be easy to consider myself to have been naive and a bit daft, but I think it would be a shame to think like that. This world lacks the innocence and magic of those times.
Since I started making crop circles I’ve come to understand the work and thought that goes into their creation. I can’t say I’ve encountered anything that made me believe a particular circle was made by aliens, though I have seen some crop circles where I’ve been amazed by the skill level of the makers. I find myself wondering how they managed it.
The two I always think of are the owl at Woodborough Hill [2009] and the grey alien [Crab Wood, Sparsholt, 2002]. They’re very different circles but they’re both incredible achievements.